Comments on: Surgery patients won’t get COVID-19 tests before their operations if they pass screens. It’s controversial. https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial Breaking news and analysis about clinical medicine, research and healthcare delivery Tue, 09 Jun 2020 03:36:59 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.5.1 By: Private surgery clinic now recommends patients get pre-operative COVID-19 testing - Medicine Matters https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-21 Tue, 09 Jun 2020 03:36:59 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-21 […] health care workers hardest hit by the COVID-1… Surgery patients won’t get COVID-19 tests before … Can dogs sniff out COVID-19? Veterinarian researchers […] ]]> By: Anonymous https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-19 Thu, 28 May 2020 01:55:04 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-19 5 ]]> By: No COVID-19 testing before surgery - rolling the dice? - Medicine Matters https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-13 Wed, 20 May 2020 21:46:41 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-13 […] health care workers hardest hit by the COVID-1… Surgery patients won’t get COVID-19 tests before … Can dogs sniff out COVID-19? Veterinarian researchers […] ]]> By: Anonymous https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-12 Tue, 19 May 2020 20:08:38 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-12 4.5 ]]> By: Tom https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-11 Sat, 16 May 2020 23:45:51 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-11 Isn’t it better to know a little than to know everything? I think this is financially and politically driven. ]]> By: Carolyn Thomas https://www.medicinematters.ca/surgery-patients-wont-get-covid-19-tests-before-their-operations-if-they-pass-screens-its-controversial/#comment-10 Sat, 16 May 2020 18:30:58 +0000 https://www.medicinematters.ca/?p=228#comment-10 Excellent overview of a disturbing reality, Pamela. When Dr. Bonnie Henry makes it clear that she’s not a fan of random testing because of the “test limitations”, it begs the question: why do we continue to rely on testing despite acknowledging such limitations? Would we continue to rely on pregnancy tests that were wrong one-third of the time?

Experts have pondered the possible reasons for test limitations, including but not limited to problems with chemical reagents used to perform the tests, the biology of the individual patient, timing (if symptoms are waning, false negatives may be more prevalent), and – perhaps most worrisome – incorrect swab placement by the person doing the nasopharyngeal testing (one physician joked – sort of! – that he wants to see cerebral spinal fluid on each swab!)

The daily briefing announcements of BC’s current COVID-19 positive cases is a joke, given the number of both sick people, asymptomatic people or dead people who are never tested. When a friend in Vancouver became ill and tested positive on March 19th (a few days after a big family birthday party at her home), none of her party guests could get tested, although several family members did later test positive. Now, with added capacity since then, we’re told that anybody who wants to be tested, can be. The public health policies, including now this policy for surgical patients that reinforces Picard’s “half-hearted” embrace of testing, are unfortunate.
regards,
C.

]]>